NCMA Polling Page Gears 640x480NCMA Member Polls and Surveys 2024 NCMA ISSUES BALLOT One ballot per member company Return ballot by COB Oct 6, 2023 Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form. - Step 1 of 3INSTRUCTIONS: One principal contact in each member company may vote for a maximum of 5 issues in each of three categories (Legislative, Regulatory, Organizational/Strategic). Rank each selection from lowest priority to highest priority. The member’s primary contact is responsible for completing one ballot representing the member company’s vote and submitting that ballot to NCMA. You may get input from as many employees as desired. Use the downloadable worksheet to share with employees for input. ▶︎ DOWNLOAD BALLOT WORKSHEET ◀︎ DEADLINE: Submit your ballot by COB Friday, October 6, 2023. Results will be shared at the annual meeting October 30 & 31, 2023. Name *FirstLastEmail *Company *LEGISLATIVE ISSUES for 2024 Vote for your top 5 Legislative Issues There are 20 legislative issue presented on the ballot. L01 • Air Toxics Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Amend General statutes to remove NC air toxics. Go after unacceptable risk clause. L02 • Recognize that biomass is carbon neutral. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Seek legislation to recognize biomass as climate positive/carbon neutral. NCMA member preferred language already drafted. L03 • Require rulemaking for Environmental Justice (EJ) requirements. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Request that any EJ requirements, including standards and applicability to permits, be adopted as rules, and prohibit DEQ’s utilization of EJ until rulemaking is complete L04 • Allow more time to correct permitting/enforcement problems. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Modify the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) to allow permittees additional time to correct problems with permits or enforcement actions, likely through a mechanism of a protective appeal that ensures OAH will not require unnecessary filings (without having to file for a continuance), plus also consider a provision that would allow the agency to agree to extend the time to file a contested case petition at OAH. L05 • Make notices of violation (NOVs) appealable. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Modify the APA to provide that notices of violation (NOVs) are appealable to the OAH even if they do not include civil penalties and modify Chapters 143 and 130A to set standards of when an NOV is appropriate and to encourage the use of alternative mechanisms for DEQ to raise compliance issues. L06 • Remove PQL as Default Groundwater Standard. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Clarify North Carolina Groundwater Standards (15A NCAC 2L) to remove assumption that the default groundwater standard in the absence of an established numerical standard is the detectable concentration at or above the practical quantitation limit (PQL). [Ref: 15A NCAC 2L .0202 (c)] L07 • Expedite and ensure time limits on IMACs. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Make Interim Maximum Allowable Concentration (IMACs) quickly available and time limited. Should be looked at with (ab)use of PQLs.IMACs should expire. Need legislature to reinforce expiration. L08 • Support further corporate tax reform. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Protect sales and use tax exceptions for raw materials, energy, machinery equipment. Oppose any efforts to eliminate or reduce sales and use tax exemptions on core manufacturing inputs. Monitor the status of state surplus tax policies and their implications. L09 • Oppose Extended Producer Rules. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Oppose new or existing plans/requirements to enact extended producer rules (a packaging tax). L10 • Exempt from NCDOL Hazardous Right-to-Know Act any facility reporting under EPCRA. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Exempt from NCDOL Hazardous Right-to-Know Act any facility reporting under EPCRA. L11 • Establish uniform pay across state agencies. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Engage legislature to bring uniformity to pay across departments to avoid one agency’s hiring advantage over another. L12 • Adopt rules to establish voluntary disclosure with penalty abatement. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Modify Chapter 143B to require DEQ to adopt rules to establish a voluntary disclosure process, whereby a regulated entity can voluntarily disclose non-compliance that are discovered through environmental audits, an ISO process or some other mechanism initiated by the regulated entity, with the result that the regulated entity is entitled to a complete or partial penalty abatement, depending on the circumstances specified in the rules. L13 • Allow for time-limited agreement in permit or enforcement appeals without ALJ approval. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Modify the APA to allow the appealing non-third-party (i.e., the permit holder or entity penalized) to mutually agree to a stay of the contested case by filing an agreement document in the proceeding without the need for ALJ approval, with this agreed-upon stay would put the case on hold for a limited period of time as stated in the amendment (perhaps 30 or 60 days). L14 • Recognize Universal Recycling Technologies. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Update the plastics recycling standards and program to reflect the availability of universal recycling technologies. L15 • Improve Brownfields program. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Modify the brownfield program: remove the prohibition against including NPL sites and direct DEQ to enter into a memorandum of understanding with EPA about handling NPL and NPL-caliber sites restructure the program overview to give more weight to the prospective developer’s (PD) consultant, perhaps using a process of accreditation similar to (but better than) the one for Registered Environmental Consultants alter the process to allow the PD the option of drafting the agreement, which should be given weight in considering the form of the final agreement provide a means by which a buyer or other entity entitled to liability protection can secure a written confirmation of coverage from DEQ. L16 • Provide incentives for innovations in recycling technologies. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Establish a legislative study commission to determine opportunities for additional incentives for voluntary activities to implement better treatment or recycling technologies or alter processes. L17 • Emerging Contaminants Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Ensure any legislation for PFAS and/or 1,4-Dioxane being considered by the General Assembly is based on best available sound science and has good definitions. L18 • Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor NC legislators’ involvement with RGGI. Oppose NC joining the RGGI. L19 • Environmental Justice Impacts on Industry Planning and Capital Investment Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor expansion of NCDEQ’s EJ policy, especially regarding permit compliance and renewal requirements. Oppose implementation of plans like that of NJ DEP. L20 • Advanced Recycling Technologies regulated as manufacturing and not solid waste Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Advocate for passing legislation that would ensure that advanced recycling technologies are properly regulated as manufacturing and not solid waste. NEXT PAGE: REGULATORY ISSUES Proceed to next page. NextREGULATORY ISSUES for 2024 Vote for your top 5 Regulatory Issues There are 19 regulatory issue presented on the ballot. R01 • Reduce bureaucracy and enhance efficiency in NCDEQ Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Reduce bureaucracy and enhance efficiency in NCDEQ R02 • Expedite environmental permitting. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Revisit ways to expedite environmental permitting. Items to consider: Offer NCMA sponsored lunch & learn events to DEQ staff. Request permit review/decision deadlines (e.g. 6 months) for all environmental permits. Track metrics: how long does it take to get permits now? R03 • Return to semiannual stormwater monitoring. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Request DEQ return quarterly monitoring to semiannual monitoring or at least provide relief if [x] number good samples in a row. R04 • Make DEQ enforcement documents more accessible. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Request/emphasize greater transparency and easier location of all enforcement documents used by DEQ. R05 • Monitor energy rates and look for least impact. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor energy rates and look for least impact. R06 • Engage DEQ’s implementation of PM 2.5 NAAQS regarding impacts to attainment. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Engage DEQ’s implementation of PM 2.5 NAAQS regarding impacts to attainment. R07 • Remove barriers to beneficial reuse. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Remove barriers to beneficial reuse. R08 • Request PFAS rulemaking stakeholder involvement. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority In cooperation with American Chemistry Council, ask DENR to include our voice in PFAS rulemaking to help regulators understand impact of actions initiated by environmental media programs. R09 • Establish NCMA strategy and priorities for DEQ to consider for 2026 10-year rules review cycle. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Establish NCMA strategy and priorities for DEQ to consider for 2026 10-year rules review cycle. R10 • Seek a statewide standard on Hexavalent Chromium background levels (naturally occurring in some locations) and Arsenic. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Seek a statewide standard on Hexavalent Chromium background levels (naturally occurring in some locations) and Arsenic. R11 • Monitor Brownfields Program changes (development vs regulatory). Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor Brownfields Program changes (development vs regulatory). R12 • Anticipate issues with bacteria criteria (triennial review). Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Issues with false results attributed to human vs animals in the wild. EPA guidance came out in July. R13 • Engage DEQ to implement PFAS fluorinated compound specific monitoring. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority The current plan is to report anything with fluorine in it. R14 • Competitive and Consistent Pay across State Agencies Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Direct DEQ to study pay, so that the legislature can ensure uniformity of pay across departments and divisions and ensure that the pay is sufficiently competitive that DEQ can attract and retain technical personnel with adequate training and experience. R15 • Air Toxics Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor and influence the implementation of regulation on air toxics. R16 • Emerging Contaminants Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor development of effluent discharge limits for PFAS. Monitor, influence, and if necessary, oppose PFAS testing for NPDES permit holders that overreach regulatory requirements and do not have properly established standards and methods for wastewater. Influence policies that are based on solid science and are not adapted from drinking water health advisory levels (PFAS and 1,4-Dioxane). Monitor the hazardous waste status of carbon/resin filters used to treat PFAS and the supply chain considerations for said carbon filters. R17 • Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor commissions and regulator engagement with this initiative. R18 • Environmental Justice Policy and Regulation Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor SEC, State Attorneys General and EPAs actions involving ESG. Comment on the recent RMP rule that left the OMB either signing on to any National level comments or initiating with an NCMA workgroup. Anticipate an EJ component. R19 • Startup/Shutdown Malfunction Rule Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Engage with NCDEQ and understand direction of SSM in response to EPA. Discourage updates to rule. Monitor and oppose any rule making development that makes SSM requirements more difficult and onerous.NEXT PAGE: ORGANIZATIONAL/STRATEGIC ISSUES Proceed to next page. PreviousNextORGANIZATIONAL ISSUES for 2024 Prioritize your top 5 Organizational/Strategic Issues There are 6 organizational/strategic issues presented on the ballot. S01 • Develop NCMA training: Risks associated with voluntary disclosures related to climate change. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Develop NCMA training: Risks associated with voluntary disclosures related to climate change. S02 • Reinvigorate NCMA PAC Board. Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Reinvigorate NCMA PAC Board. S03 • Appointments to Boards and Commissions Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Monitor and advocate for business-friendly appointments for boards and commissions. S04 • Relationships with DEQ Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Maintain a relationship of mutual trust, cooperation, and collaboration with both management and staff of the agency. S05 • Industry Coordination and Collaboration Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Find common ground with other stakeholder organizations on issues of shared interests for mutual gain. Lead and/or participate in workgroups with stakeholders when warranted. With help from the American Chemistry Council, identify companies effected by or set to benefit from the Advanced Recycling Rule and bring them to the table for collaboration as member companies. Collaborate with agricultural groups and economic developers to influence EJ policy. S06 • New Members (copy) Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityThird PrioritySecond PriorityHighest Priority Fifth PriorityItem #1 Fifth PriorityFourth PriorityItem #1 Fourth PriorityThird PriorityItem #1 Third PrioritySecond PriorityItem #1 Second PriorityHighest PriorityItem #1 Highest Priority Increase membership by collaborating with companies not currently involved with NCMA but have similar interests (including Advanced Recycling). Consider NCMA membership for nontraditional companies like agribusiness and furniture industry. Also underrepresented companies (i.e. sectors that do not have their own trade organizations) Submit